AI Disclosure Requirements

PHYS 3209: Electronics I

1 Overview

Our policy on AI tools is based on the American Physical Society (APS) Physical Review journals’ policy, updated in June 2026 (American Physical Society 2026b, 2026a). The idea is simple: AI tools may be used only on your lab reports. If you use them, you must say how, and you are responsible for everything in your report.

This page covers generative AI tools such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, and similar systems, including AI features built into editors, coding environments, and circuit simulators.

Note

AI use is entirely optional. You are never required to use generative AI in this course.

Photo of a 1979 IBM training slide reading: A computer can never be held accountable. Therefore a computer must never make a management decision.

IBM training slide, 1979 (IBM 1979)

Relying on AI is not free. There is growing evidence that it can erode the skills it replaces:

“The ADR of standard colonoscopy decreased significantly from 28.4% (226 of 795) before to 22.4% (145 of 648) after exposure to AI, corresponding with an absolute difference of -6.0% (95% CI -10.5 to -1.6; p=0.0089). […] Continuous exposure to AI might reduce the ADR of standard non-AI assisted colonoscopy, suggesting a negative effect on endoscopist behaviour.” (Budzyń et al. 2025)

Analyzing a circuit by hand, building it, and finding out why it does not work are the skills this course exists to build. Improper use of AI leaves you worse off, rather than better.

2 Where AI Is Allowed

Work AI tools
Pre-lab exercises Not permitted
In-class lab worksheets and bench work (including microcontroller code written in lab) Not permitted
Quizzes Not permitted
Lab reports Permitted, with disclosure

The pre-labs, worksheets, and quizzes are where you practice and show the skills yourself: they prepare you for the bench, and they tell both of us whether you are ready for the next lab. Lab reports are written outside class, as a scientist would write a paper, so they follow the APS rules.

3 The Principles

  1. You are accountable. An AI program cannot be held accountable (IBM 1979), so it cannot be an author. You are responsible for the accuracy of every sentence, number, equation, figure, schematic, and reference in your report, whether or not AI helped produce it.
  2. Check everything. Review and correct all AI output before it goes into your report. AI tools confidently produce wrong circuit analysis, wrong code, and references that do not exist.
  3. Disclose substantive use. If AI shaped the science or the content of your report, say so in the report.
  4. Keep a record. Note your AI use as you go. Save chat links or transcripts until your report is graded; I may ask to see them.

4 When Must I Disclose?

We draw a line between light editing and substantive use.

No disclosure needed: using AI to polish, condense, or lightly edit text you wrote. This means spelling, grammar, punctuation, word choice, and trimming a sentence that runs long. The meaning, the claims, and the structure stay yours. If the AI rewrote a paragraph into something you would not have written, that is no longer light editing.

Disclosure required: any use that affects the content or the results of your report. That includes:

  • Writing or debugging code that produces your fits, numbers, or plots (for example, a Bode plot or a fit to a diode I–V curve)
  • Performing or checking circuit analysis, derivations, calculations, or uncertainty propagation
  • Generating or restyling figures, schematics, or diagrams
  • Finding, summarizing, or synthesizing literature or datasheet information for your Introduction or Theory
  • Interpreting your results or suggesting explanations for a discrepancy between your measurements and your circuit model
  • Drafting or restructuring text (see What Is Not Permitted for the limits)
  • Translating text from another language
TipWhen in doubt, disclose

A disclosure costs you one sentence.

5 Where Does the Disclosure Go?

The disclosure goes in a section titled AI Disclosure at the end of your report, after the References and any appendices. It is part of the report, not a separate document. If you used AI only for light editing, or not at all, you may leave the section out. If your report also needs a Data Disclosure section (for raw lab data you did not help collect; see the syllabus), put the two sections together at the end.

6 What Goes in the Disclosure?

List each substantive use. Every entry answers four questions:

Required item What to include
1. Tool and version The tool’s name and version or model, e.g. “ChatGPT (GPT-5)”, “Claude Sonnet 5”, “GitHub Copilot in VS Code”.
2. How it assisted What the AI did, and where in the report: wrote a plotting script for Fig. 2, checked the transfer-function derivation in Sec. 2, suggested a figure layout.
3. How you directed it What you asked it to do, and what you gave it (your code, your equations, your draft). A one-line summary of your prompt is enough.
4. How you verified the output How you know the result is right: compared to a hand calculation, checked the code against a case with a known answer, read each reference yourself.

Item 4 is the one that matters most. “I read it over” is not verification.

7 Example

AI Disclosure

  1. Claude Sonnet 5. I described the layout I wanted for the Bode plot of the RC low-pass filter (Fig. 2), and it drafted the Python plotting script in Appendix A. I checked the plotted points against my data table and confirmed that the model curve crosses −3 dB at the cutoff frequency I calculated by hand in Sec. 2.
  2. GitHub Copilot (VS Code, January 2027). It suggested the function for the weighted least-squares fit of the diode I–V curve (Sec. 3). I verified the fit by running it on simulated data generated with known parameters and recovering them within their uncertainties.
  3. ChatGPT (GPT-5). I asked it for feedback on the organization of my Discussion, which led me to move the comparison with the datasheet values earlier. All text is my own.

8 What Is Not Permitted

APS now allows authors to use AI substantively, with disclosure, but this course must assess your understanding. The following are not permitted, disclosed or not:

  • Using AI on pre-lab exercises, in-class lab worksheets and bench work, or quizzes. This includes having AI analyze a circuit, debug your breadboard, or write microcontroller code during lab.
  • Generating, altering, or “filling in” data. Every data point must come from real measurements taken in the lab. Raw lab data you did not help collect must be identified in a Data Disclosure section at the end of your report.
  • Having AI write your report or its sections. Your Abstract, Discussion, and Conclusion must be written by you. AI may give feedback on your draft; it may not produce the draft.
  • Citing sources you have not read. AI tools invent references. Every citation must point to a real source that you have looked at and that says what you claim it says.
  • Presenting AI-generated images as real. A schematic or diagram may be AI-assisted and disclosed; it may never be passed off as a photograph or a screen capture of your measurements.
  • Using AI substantively without disclosing it.
Important

Undisclosed substantive AI use, or any of the uses above, may be treated as a violation of Georgia Tech’s academic integrity policies.

9 Why This Matters

This policy is not meant to discourage legitimate use of useful tools. Working physicists and engineers use them, and APS (and other journals) acknowledge that. This is meant to keep your reports honest about how they were made, and to make sure the electronics in them is yours.

TipQuestions?

If you are not sure whether a use is allowed or needs disclosing, ask before you submit.

10 Acknowledgements

TBD.

11 References

American Physical Society. 2026a. “American Physical Society Releases Updated AI Policy for Journals.” June 17. https://www.aps.org/about/news/2026/06/releases-updated-ai-policy-journals.
American Physical Society. 2026b. “Appropriate Use of AI-Based Writing Tools.” June 17. https://journals.aps.org/authors/appropriate-use-ai-tools.
Budzyń, K. et al. 2025. “Endoscopist Deskilling Risk After Exposure to Artificial Intelligence in Colonoscopy: A Multicentre, Observational Study.” Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology 10 (10): 896–903. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2468-1253(25)00133-5.
IBM. 1979. A Computer Can Never Be Held Accountable, Therefore a Computer Must Never Make a Management Decision. Internal training presentation slide; original lost, image first posted online in February 2017. https://simonwillison.net/2025/Feb/3/a-computer-can-never-be-held-accountable/.